Cut to order
Whole, butterflied, skinned, or portioned exactly the way your recipe calls for.
Pristine local catch, trusted fishermen, and the kind of straight answers you only get from a neighborhood fish market.
Selection changes with the boats and the weather. Call before you make the trip for live availability.
Fresh Catch Seafood began with a simple promise: buy as close to the dock as possible, handle every fish with care, and never sell what we wouldn’t bring home ourselves.
We work with independent fishermen across Long Island and the Northeast, choosing quality over quantity every single morning.
Whole, butterflied, skinned, or portioned exactly the way your recipe calls for.
Carefully wrapped and iced so your catch stays cold all the way to your kitchen.
Ask our fishmongers what’s best today—and the simplest way to make it shine.
Cold water, clean tides, and a crisp mineral finish. Our rotating local selection is harvested nearby and delivered fresh to the case.
Serve well chilled with lemon—or nothing at all.
Stop in, ask questions, and let us point you toward the best catch of the day.
This form is a demo and does not send requests. Call (631) 335-6439 to confirm availability and order for pickup.
Demo only: no request is sent or saved. Call (631) 335-6439 to order.No request was sent. Call (631) 335-6439 and a fishmonger will help confirm your order and pickup time.